šµ Lessons to learn from Metallica's irresistable charm offensive
The subtle, savvy marketing genius that we can all take a few pointers from
This weekend just gone, I was up in Cardiff to see Metallica play at the Principality Stadium. Cardiff is fairly unique in that their stadium is bang in the centre of the city, and as a consequence, when a band like Metallica plays, it is tantamount to an invasion. Thousands of fans, all clad in their Metallica shirt of choice, roaming the streets, with every bar playing the band's music and a pervading sense that, on this gloriously sunny day, everyone is going to have one seriously great time.
Metallica are a band I find endlessly fascinating. Attend one of their concerts, and the demographic range on show is quite unlike anything I have seen elsewhere: all ages (literally - from kids to pensioners!), and curiously well split between men and women.
Let's be clear: Metallica are a thrash metal band. If you hit up one of their shows in the 90s, I would think "sausage fest" is likely to be a fair summary of the gender split. Ergo, to see women in their 50s, 60s or more wandering about, proudly clad in their Metallica shirts, is both amazing and simultaneously puzzling for those of us who recall their gigs back in the day when seeing any women at all was almost a novelty.
After the success of their self-titled "black album", the band has been at large arena or stadium levels. Maintaining that for the subsequent 30+ years, however, is a feat very few have managed. In fact, in 2026 I'd argue the band are bigger than ever, with the current M72 tour looking to end a full four years after it began.
Has the band's album output grown in correlation with their stadium-filling, millions-reached touring? I would politely suggest it has not; check their set lists and you will see a heavy weighting towards material up to the black album, with fewer and fewer from each subsequent release thereafter. This graph is a little out of date, but illustrates the point nonetheless:
That makes for quite a strange juxtaposition. Most bands fail to hold this kind of status if their albums are not matching the last for sales, especially in this day and age where interest in artists wanes faster than ever.
So how have Metallica maintained this? It is a question I find myself pondering, usually when reading about their latest moves, such as a string of dates at the billion dollar Sphere venue in Las Vegas that kicks off this October.
For me, the answer is relatively simple: Metallica understands fan service, and mounts a charm offensive to an extent rarely seen among modern bands.
Let's take the band's upcoming London dates this weekend as a case in point. As well as playing two nights at the London Stadium, the following band-related events are also happening:
A pop-up store on Old Street, running for five days (which I note had fans queuing overnight to be first into)
A Q&A with guitarist Kirk Hammett at the Earth theatre in Hackney
A Metallica film festival at the Prince Charles Cinema in Leicester Square
A Metallica covers band night at the Underworld in Camden
Invitations for fans to help out at food banks the band in sponsoring whilst over
Invitations to give blood at agreed venues in collaboration with the NHS
That is just the events. In addition, every date on the tour has its own limited run t-shirt and poster design, the bulk of which are only on sale at the pop-ups. Furthermore, in the queue for the pop-up store, scratch cards are being handed out to those waiting. Winners will get a free pass to the Snake Pit - the central area that the band's staging encircles at their in-the-round M72 stage setup. At the bandās previous tour, I will never forget seeing roadies going around the crowd, handing out event-specific Metallica-branded plectrums to the kids. My son got one, and still has it to this day.
Then there is also the local recognition from the band; at the Cardiff show, bassist Rob Trujillo talked about seeing (Welsh metallers) Skindred at a show in town the night before, and how much he loved Cardiff Castle, all before joining Kirk Hammett in a rendition of Tom Jones' "Delilah", which - as you can imagine - went down a storm with the (predominantly) proudly Welsh audience.
In digesting all of the above, a simple fact might have passed you by: none of these events are online. None are particularly digitally-focused. That is not to say that Metallica is not digitally engaged: they absolutely are. Crucially though, I feel there is a clear understanding that real life moments carry infinitely more value. Hence, when this band hits town, you better believe they're going to make it count.
The band's YouTube strategy - though really, its filming strategy - pairs with this approach beautifully. At what I'd imagine is no small cost, the band film each show with full multi-camera setups, but tracks from shows are then posted to the band's YouTube channel, ensuring fans have an endless source of moments to relive from each tour, all shot to the highest standard.
Doubtless much of this might see cynical readers rolling their eyes and thinking "OK, but that's Metallica; they're not an ordinary band". That may be true, but I still feel there is a vast amount to learn from the way this band has connected with fans.
In short, they understand fan service as a concept.
When working with Run The Jewels, I once described this as the balance between the āgiveā versus the ātakeā. If you give a little, you earn the right to then take - by which I mean, ask fans to spend money on you. In RTJ's case, it is tough to underestimate how much goodwill was earned with fans by making every album available for free to download. That in turn leads to fans happily spending money on vinyl, merch, tickets and more. Why? Because the band started with a give.
Metallica follows a similar logic: by making so much effort to not just connect with fans but even recognise that one should connect with that city's fans on their level - singing local songs, chatting about local spots and doing so with a genuine sense of passion for the area. Again, cynics might decry this as a clever marketing move. They might even be right, who knows? One thing is irrefutable though: it absolutely works.
For me, understanding that āgive versus takeā mentality is a critical part of marketing. Too often, we get bogged down in platform talk; which ones to focus on, how to tweak the algorithm and so on. What Metallica shows, in my view, is that marketing is, was, and always will be about connection - and connections are most powerful when they happen in real life, and they certainly don't rely on technical platforms in order to take place.
These are simple truths, but ones that many companies try very hard to obfuscate.
Don't fall for all that. Connection is a powerful human thing, and we should all be looking at how we focus on that, rather than algorithmic success, or virality, or whatever other terms now reside purely in the digital realm. Metrics, digital moments, even viralityā¦ it all comes and goes quickly. Make a meaningful human connection with a fan, however, and you may well have them for life.
And if you need proof of it working in practice, just look at Metallica.
Have a great day,
D.
š§ listening to āWhite Pepperā by Ween. Yes, I am on a Ween kick right now. As their more commercial album, White Pepper is a wondrous summer listen. Bright, breezy melodies and a generally upbeat vibe ensures that this is a perfect match to the summer heatwave weāre briefly enjoying a respite from (only 28 today!) but will soon be plunging back into next week.
š reading Greg Graffinās autobiography, āPunk Paradox: A Memoirā. As the singer and co-founder of Bad Religion, Greg Graffin holds a unique position, being both a legendary punk vocalist, and a preminent professor in the field of evolutionary science. His book is therefore quite the read, balancing both these callings and generally making for a breath of fresh air from the usual rock stay autobiography. If you were ever a fan of Bad Religion, itās a must-read.
š¤ loving my Xteink X3 e-reader. This Ā£50 gem does just the one thing, in that it opens all e-book formats (epub, mobi etc) andā¦ thatās it. However this thing is tiny too, and comes with a magnetic ring allowing you to fix it to the back of your phone. This all might sound daft when phones can open ebooks, but this is about purpose and utility for me: it can sit in my pocket, taking up minimal space, and I can read without distraction. Wonderful. Heartily recommended!
Gleefully accepting music recommendations!
I do really enjoy getting suggestions for either existing music or forthcoming releases to check out. So, if thereās something you think I might like, do feel free to get in touch. Always keen to hear the weird and wonderful things going on out there. And, with 6000+ subscribers, Iām happy to spread word on things Iām loving too.